DESIGN COMPARISON

Compare designs with a preference test.

Show two to four logos, packs, mockups or concepts to your audience. People can choose a favourite, explain why, name their runner-up or rate an option out of 5.

Two matcha tin designs placed side by side on a work table
Use one criterion to compare both designs

What should you ask when comparing two designs?

Give the respondent a situation and a criterion. Choosing a pack on a shelf, recognising a logo and understanding a mockup are different decisions.

Packaging

“If they cost the same, which would you pick off the shelf?” Add a rating for how easily the product name can be read.

Logo

“Which do you recognise most easily at this size?” Compare the logos at the same scale.

Mockup, ad or thumbnail

“Which one communicates the message fastest?” Show each page, banner or thumbnail as it would appear on the same device.

Run a useful preference test

  1. Set up the comparison. Use the same image size, price and context across versions if you want to isolate the design choice.
  2. Ask for a favourite and a reason. Offer a “None” option and ask what tipped the balance.
  3. Read ratings alongside the votes. A design can catch the eye while making text harder to read. Check both signals before deciding.
  4. Follow up in context. If preferences are close or comments point in different directions, refine the designs and test again on the shelf, on screen or with another relevant group.

For more on comparing design options, see UserTesting’s definition of a preference test.

Questions about design preference testing

How does this differ from an A/B test on a website?

A preference test asks people to compare options directly. In a website A/B test, different groups see one version each and you track an observable action such as a click or purchase.

How many options can I compare?

VIFLY Pulse supports two to four options, with or without images. Results show the vote and rating counts for each. You can filter reasons and suggestions by voter group.

Who takes part in the test?

Share the link with the people whose feedback you want. Choose respondents who fit your target audience. For a retail product, think about the shelf, price and purchase situation.

Which design would your audience choose?

Want to check the concept first? Run a business idea test.

Create a design preference test ↗